"And what does the LORD require of you But to do justice, to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God"
-- Micah 6:8

"The duty of the prosecutor is to seek justice, not merely to convict."
-- American Bar Association Standard 3-1.2(c)

"There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war and applying the death penalty, but not however with regard to abortion and euthanasia."
--Pope Benedict XVI, June 2004

Monday, May 17, 2010

Group of Five Strikes a Blow for Criminals

Well, the Ivy-League Group of Five has issued another proclamation from on high, this time deciding that the State of Florida imposed a cruel and unusual punishment on a juvenile robber by sentencing him to life without parole (LWOP) (Graham v. Florida).

The Wise Men (and Woman) tell us that it is morally disproportionate to sentence a juvenile violent offender to LWOP for any crime short of homicide. Their Constitutional argument? Well, by golly, the Court itself has decided that only the Court gets to decide whether a particular penal practice violates the Eighth Amendment... so in effect, a bare majority of five ivy-league, ivory-tower justices can override the democratically enacted laws of the people to whom the Founders entrusted the question of what is or is not a "cruel or unusual" punishment. The cloak for this naked exercise of raw political power is that our five Oligarchs will first determine that "evolving standards [sic] of decency" require that they intervene to declare a punishment to be in violation of the Eighth Amendment.

Justice Thomas makes this modest reply:
The news of this evolution will, I think, come as a surprise to the American people. Congress, the District ofColumbia, and 37 States allow judges and juries to consider this sentencing practice in juvenile nonhomicidecases, and those judges and juries have decided to use it in the very worst cases they have encountered.
The Court does not conclude that life without paroleitself is a cruel and unusual punishment. It instead rejects the judgments of those legislatures, judges, and juries regarding what the Court describes as the "moral"question of whether this sentence can ever be "proportionat[e]" when applied to the category of offenders at issue here. Ante, at 7 (internal quotation marks omitted), ante, at 1 (STEVENS, J., concurring).
I am unwilling to assume that we, as members of thisCourt, are any more capable of making such moral judgments than our fellow citizens. Nothing in our training as judges qualifies us for that task, and nothing in Article III gives us that authority.
Justice Stevens, who is thankfully retiring, chastised Justice Thomas' "rigid" approach (meaning: respect the limited role of the judiciary and let the legislative branch set punishments). Quoth Stevens, "Standards of decency have evolved since 1980. They will never stop doing so."

We well know that criminal advocates and death penalty abolitionists fondly hope and dream that these so-called "standards" will evolve so much that the death penalty will be considered inhumane, and all LWOP sentences cruel and unusual. By the way-- what kind of "standard" is it that undergoes constant flux according the moral judgment of the Ivy League fraternity that is the 5-justice majority?

The march of the criminal's lobby goes on, looking for the day when the death penalty is again ruled unconstitutional, and states are forbidden even from imposing LWOP on offenders. Once the principle is admitted that long periods of incarceration can be violative of the Eighth Amendment, the sky is the limit for the crime lobby, and after LWOP falls, mandatory minimum sentences will be next.

Is there any doubt where Elena Kagan will end up on this issue?

7 comments:

明NathanA_Schulle said...

大家隨便說,說什麽都好,就是請不要惦惦.............................................

京蕙 said...

777成人貼圖區 激情視訊 1069聊天 免費線上a 一葉情交友 av免費看女優 性感卡通美女圖片 成人線上影片觀賞 熟女自拍偷拍 dd 豆豆聊聊天室 性愛愛無碼影片 情趣成人圖片 18禁網站 少女卡通圖 777線上影城 忍者a片 咪咪情色貼圖 色情免費下載影片 一夜情網路交友 a383girl影音 完美女聊天 玩美影音 線上美女 辣妹脫衣 人妻自拍分享 熟女,貼圖 護士 空姐 a圖貼片區 日本女郎寫真集 85cc線上免費影片 微風成人 嘟嘟 777中部人聊天室 性貼圖區 學生性愛援交 情人視訊辣妹 鋼管 免費av線上觀看 洪爺情色電影 大奶. sex無碼影片 免下載色情網站 日本正妹巨乳照片 愛情性遊戲區 後宮電影電影院入口 限制級 成人視訊0204 女人性愛貼片 乳頭走光

柏懿綺辰 said...

你不能決定生命的長度,但你可以控制它的寬度..................................................

琳欣劉元慈 said...

精彩的文章是我停留的理由~........................................

瓊文TamMcfee0520 said...

you look nice in that color!............................................................

冠慧 said...

人間好話,要如海綿遇水牢牢吸住..................................................................

冠慧 said...

You are flattering me..................................................